Bounded Verification of Voting Software

We present a case-study in which vote-tallying software is analyzed using a bounded verification technique, whereby all executions of a procedure are exhaustively examined within a finite space given by a bound on the size of the heap and the number of loop unrollings. The technique involves an encoding of the procedure in an intermediate relational programming language, a translation of that language to relational logic, and an analysis of the logic that exploits recent advances in finite model-finding. Our technique yields concrete counterexamples – traces of the procedure that violate the specification. The vote-tallying software, used for public elections in the Netherlands, had previously been annotated with specifications in the Java Modeling Language and analyzed with ESC/Java2. Our analysis found counterexamples to the JML contracts, indicating bugs in the code and errors in the specifications that evaded prior analysis.